Treaty Legal Research

Treaty Legal Research

Self contained regimes, Unity or plurality of International Law

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Mahdieh Nazerian 1
Mozhgan Raminnia 2
1 Senior student of international law Azad University Damavand Branch
2 Faculty Member of Payame Noor University and Assistant Professor of Payame Noor University
Abstract
Abstract
 In resent years, Plurality of international law has attracted the attention of international law juirsts. Pluralism as a process in the international legal system, while creating the creation of norms, facilities, and the birth of subsystems , lead to the emergence of antagonism and Conflict in international law. This plurality occurs more in the form of self-sustaining systems. In this regard, contradiction between the plurality and unity of the international law is considerable.Commission in its 2006 report applied some strategies  to resolve disputes in plurality and create unity Using the general legal principles, stated that self-centered systems and the diversity of rules did not lead to inconsistencies in the rules. and for approving it indicated the guidelines impose specific rules and regulations governing the rights of the late international treaties.Hence, according to the Commission and by reference to the judicial court judgments international law's state haven't been dispersed in the face of self-contained system.
In resent years, Plurality of international law has attracted the attention of international law juirsts. Pluralism as a process in the international legal system, while creating the creation of norms, facilities, and the birth of subsystems , lead to the emergence of antagonism and Conflict in international law. This plurality occurs more in the form of self-sustaining systems. In this regard, contradiction between the plurality and unity of the international law is considerable.Commission in its 2006 report applied some strategies to resolve disputes in plurality and create unity Using the general legal principles, stated that self-centered systems and the diversity of rules did not lead to inconsistencies in the rules. and for approving it indicated the guidelines impose specific rules and regulations governing the rights of the late international treaties.Hence, according to the Commission and by reference to the judicial court judgments international law's state haven't been dispersed in the face of self-contained system.
Keywords
Unity
plurality
Self-contained systems and regimes
International Legal System
International Law

  1. References:

    A) Persian sources

    1. Piltan, Farzad, Legal Regime of Dispute Resolution in the World Trade Organization, Journal of Law and Politics, Spring and Summer, No. 17, 2012.

    1. Office of Commercial and Authorized Trade Representation of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Newsletter of Events and Developments of the World Trade Organization, Year 6, No. 42, December 2002.
      1. Raminia, Mojgan, The place of time factor in the interpretation of international treaty, Tehran: Shahr-e-Danesh, No. 26, 2014.
      2. Zamani, Ghasem, Shahbazi, Aramesh, Farjam International Law (oscillation between technique and prudence), Tehran: Shahrdarshan, 2010.
      3. Salimi Turkmani, Hojjat, self-sufficient regimes and its relations with public international law, International Legal Journal, No. 42, 2010.
      4. Salimi Turkmani, Hojjat, the position of self-sufficient regimes and its impact on the general rights of international responsibility, 2009.
      5. World Trade Organization, Trade in the Future, Introduction to the World Trade Organization, Institute of Business Studies and Research, February 30, 2009.
      6. Shahbazi, Aramesh, International Law System (Unity in Multiplicity), Tehran: Shahr-e-Danesh, 2010.
      7. Shirvi, Abdolhossein, International Commercial Law, Tehran: Organization for the Study and Compilation of University Humanities Books (Samt), 2015.
      8. Abedini, Abdullah, Plurality of International Law, International Legal Journal, Presidential Center for Legal Affairs, 2010.
      9. Guillaume, Gilbert, Is the Integrity of Public International Law Endangered Today ?, Journal of Legal and Political Research, No. 13, 2004.
      10. Suffocation, Zaha, the role of the International Law Commission in maintaining the unity and integrity of international law. Dissertation, Mofid University of Qom: Department of Law, International Law, 2011.

    B) English sources


    1.  
      Disposal of the receiving states to counter any such abuse.(1923), see Case of the s.s. Wimbledon P.C.I.J. Series A No.1.

     

    1. Gerhard H , "Pros and Cons Ensuing from Fragmentation of International Law", 25 Mich. J. Int'l L, )2004).
    2. ILC (International Law Commission), Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law (A/CN.4/L.682), 2006.
    3. Runersten, Michael. Defining Self-contained Regime, Faculty of law. Tesis University of Loud, 2008. available at:

     http://www.jur.lu.se/Internet/Biblioteket/Examensarbeten.nsf/0/ F7869 D 3860 52E808 C1257432004AEB8D/$File/exam.pdf? OpenElement

    1. Simma B and  Plukowski D, "Of Planets and the Universe: Self-Contained Regims in International Law", European Journal of International Law, vol. 17, no. 3, )2006(.

     

     

  • Receive Date 19 December 2018
  • Revise Date 12 May 2020
  • Accept Date 20 April 2020